Effort to terminate Charlestown’s Indian affairs attorney fails
Stay Connected with South County Star
Charlestown will continue to retain its assistant solicitor for Indian affairs after the Town Council voted against terminating his contract.
Solicitor Joseph Larisa has been with the town as counsel on Indian affairs since 2003, advising town councilors and other staff on matters related to the Narragansett Indian Tribe, whose 1,800-acre reservation is within the boundaries of Charlestown.
Larisa is paid a $2,000 per month retainer, plus $50 for expenses. He receives additional compensation at the rate of $130 an hour for litigation work.
At the council’s June 8 meeting, Town Council President Deb Carney made a motion to terminate Larisa’s contract and put out a request for proposals for an Indian affairs attorney to be used on an as-needed basis. The motion failed 3 to 2.
It was the third time since 2021 that an unsuccessful attempt was made to end Larisa’s contract with the town.
Carney cited multiple reasons for wanting to end Larisa’s retainer, including what she described as a more positive relationship between the town and tribe, and a reduced need for Larisa’s services in recent years.
“I don’t like having a solicitor on staff to oppose particular individuals,” Carney said in an interview. “He’s not the only Indian affairs attorney out there.”
Prior to voting, town councilors heard from two members of the Narragansett Indian Tribe who were in attendance.
“No other group is singled out like the tribe has been singled out,” Chief Sachem Anthony Dean Stanton told councilors. “No other people have been targeted the way the tribe has been targeted.”
Robin Spears, Jr., a member of the tribe who said he is also a Charlestown resident and taxpayer, said, “We don’t need Mr. Larisa.”
“I have to agree with President Carney,” Spears said. “I stand behind you.”
Larisa has represented the town in numerous issues related to the tribe, including issues stemming from the state’s high-profile smoke shop raid in 2003, land sovereignty disputes, as well as civil rights and police matters.
At the meeting, Larisa defended his position, saying he brings a “wealth of institutional experience” to his job.
He pushed back on Carney’s position that the town’s other attorneys, Peter Ruggiero and Robert Craven, could assume responsibility for Indian affairs matters in the future.
“Both of them, whenever there’s anything having to do with the Narragansett Indian Tribe, it’s 1-800-Joe Larisa. They don’t go near it,” Larisa said. “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.”
Larisa argued that his compensation arrangement helps contain costs because routine consultations are covered by the monthly retainer.
“It’s all you can eat,” he said.
Larisa pointed out that he has not raised his rates since signing on with the town 23 years ago.
“Instead of an increase, it’s stayed the same. Have I complained? No,” he said. “I love protecting the town. I’ve been here since the beginning.”
Larisa denied suggestions that his position targets the Narragansett Indian Tribe and said he has worked collaboratively with the tribe in the past.
Town councilors Bonnie Van Slyke and Stephen Stokes spoke in favor of maintaining Larisa’s contract.
“We’re talking about tribal law, we’re talking about federal law, we’re talking about state law,” Van Slyke said. “I think it’s important to have expert counsel that is available and that it’s consistent. And I do believe these services are offered at a very reasonable cost.”
Stokes pointed out the police chief says he “utilizes the service regularly.”
“I think it’s a very unique and specialized thing, so I don’t see an issue with having some type of legal counsel for that specifically,” Stokes said. “It’s not something that is done as a punishment … It’s there to protect the town.”
Councilor Craig Marr, who also voted against terminating the contract, said the issue was relatively new to him and suggested maintaining the existing arrangement while encouraging additional dialogue between Larisa and tribal members.
Councilor Peter Slom joined Carney in voting to terminate Larisa’s contract.
