Housing needs, preserving rural character dominate Charlestown council race

Charlestown Town Council candidates participate in a recent candidate forum hosted by the League of Women Voters of South County. From left: Deborah Carney, Stephen Stokes, Jill Fonnemann, Sasha Puchalski, Craig Marr, Cynthia Drummond, Bonnita Van Slyke. Photo by Alex Nunes/South County Star
Charlestown Town Council candidates participate in a recent candidate forum hosted by the League of Women Voters of South County. From left: Deborah Carney, Stephen Stokes, Jill Fonnemann, Sasha Puchalski, Craig Marr, Cynthia Drummond, Bonnita Van Slyke. Photo by Alex Nunes/South County Star

Major Sponsors

Westerly Community Credit Union logo

Addressing the town’s significant housing needs while preserving the scenic character that draws people to Charlestown has emerged as the top issue in this year’s Town Council race.

Eight candidates are vying for seats on the five-member council: Democrats Deborah Carney, Cynthia Drummond and Jill Fonnemann, independents Sasha Puchalski and Bonnita Van Slyke, and Republicans Craig Marr, Stephen Stokes and Matthew Westover. 

In candidate questionnaires and at a recent League of Women Voters of South County candidate forum, candidates described Charlestown’s shortage of affordable housing as a critical issue. 

According to HousingWorks Rhode Island, a Charlestown household would need more than $192,000 in annual income to affordably purchase a median-priced home in town, which now costs more than $630,000 — a 52% increase since 2019. 

The nonprofit’s most recent fact book says the median household income in Charlestown is about $103,000.

At 3.99%, the town is well below the state’s goal of having at least 10% of each municipality’s housing stock qualify as low- or moderate-income housing. 

“The number one priority is providing housing that is affordable for our workforce, seniors, and families,” Carney, the current Town Council president, said.

Puchalski called the affordability challenge and its impact on people’s ability to move to Charlestown a “massive issue. 

“We are an aging community and we really need to be able to bring in young families,” Marr, who currently serves on the council, said.

Candidates offered different approaches to increasing housing opportunities in Charlestown, while some expressed concerns about state efforts to encourage additional development. 

Stokes, a Town Council incumbent, said the town needs to look beyond simply expanding opportunities for homeownership.

“We should focus our efforts into rental style units,” he said.

Puchalski recommended engagement with the town’s Affordable Housing Commission, and Van Slyke, a Town Council incumbent, suggested the town look to the affordable housing plan that’s already been developed.

Marr and Carney suggested the town explore ways to partner with South County Habitat for Humanity, which is based in Charlestown.

Carney said the town needs a “multi-pronged approach.”

While acknowledging the need for more housing, candidates also expressed concerns about state laws that compel towns to allow denser development.

Drummond said a priority should be finding ways to work with the state on addressing housing, “rather than having a single mandate presented to the towns, which differ considerably in size and infrastructure.”

“Land use changes and mandates that are coming down from the state will have a significant impact on rural towns,” Westover, who did not attend the candidate forum, said in his questionnaire response. “These changes do not fit the rural characteristics of many of Rhode Island’s towns and that’s a problem.”

Candidates emphasized that Charlestown does not have townwide drinking water or sewer service, and those infrastructure limitations should be factored into decisions about growth.



Multiple candidates highlighted the importance of Charlestown’s coastline and natural environment to both community well-being and the town’s economy. 

Van Slyke said the environment “is the basis for our economy” and that Charlestown can have both economic development and environmental protection. 

Drummond said the town derives value from its tourism economy and the property taxes paid by people living in shoreline homes.

“The coastline is Charlestown’s main economic driver and must be preserved,” she said. 

“We need to keep Charlestown a destination,” Fonnemann said. “We live in a very unique, special place.”

Several candidates said the town is currently well-run and should maintain the course it’s on. Candidates also said the town could advance environmental stewardship by enforcing current ordinances. Carney pointed out the value of town specialists who can guide decision-making.

The future of Ninigret Park emerged as the most contentious issue at the League of Women Voters candidate forum. 

For years, officials and residents have debated the extent to which the town should expand offerings at the 227-acre park. 

Stokes joked that, in Charlestown, Ninigret Park’s future is akin to controversial national political issues.

“We always go back to the debate of nothing or giant football stadiums, and that’s not the case,” Stokes said.

He said incremental improvements, like the installation of public art sponsored by the South County Tourism Council, are changes “we can get behind.”

Van Slyke said elected officials should respect the opinions widely expressed by residents who don’t want to see substantial changes to Ninigret Park.

Carney said some people do want to see additional recreational opportunities in the park. Marr said the town should put more money into projects that could provide more opportunities for youth in Charlestown.

“It’s embarrassing we don’t have a baseball field,” he said.

No candidate expressed support for installing permanent lights in Ninigret Park.

In response to a candidate forum question about improving cooperation, public engagement and trust in town government, Carney said progress has been made by recording town meetings, making them available online and producing more detailed meeting minutes. 

Van Slyke said the town needs to become more efficient and suggested holding fewer special meetings that are difficult for members of the public to keep track of.

Marr called on members of the public to step forward to take on volunteer roles on town committees.

Drummond suggested creating a community advisory commission.

“You have to find a way to get people to volunteer to participate in their town,” Drummond said. “Engagement is the big thing.”

Correction: An earlier version of this story misspelled candidate Stephen Stokes’ name.

Similar Posts