|

Westerly looks to Newport as model for short-term rental restrictions

A summer rental home is advertised in Westerly on Tuesday, Aug. 18. Photo by Nancy Burns-Fusaro

Stay Connected with South County Star

The Westerly Town Council has taken an initial step toward considering new short-term rental regulations modeled after restrictions in Newport. 

In a 4-2 vote Monday night, the council asked Town Solicitor William Conley to draft a potential ordinance incorporating Newport’s restrictions while creating an overlay district for coastal areas of Westerly. 

Newport’s rules prohibit property owners in residential zones from renting their homes for less than 30 days unless the property is their primary residence. Owners who live at the property can rent up to two rooms to a maximum of four people. 

Short-term rentals in Newport are also prohibited in the Limited Business Zone unless the property owner has a special use permit. Short-term rentals are allowed in designated business and waterfront zones. 

Newport also establishes filing and registration fees, with different fees depending on the type of property. 

Three Westerly town councilors who serve on a short-term rental working group — Alexandra Healy, Michael Niemeyer and Dylan LaPietra — have proposed restrictions that would prohibit short-term rentals in non-shoreline areas unless property owners live at the property. 

“The point of this is to protect the character of neighborhoods and communities,” Niemeyer said at Monday’s meeting.

LaPietra said the proposed ordinance would allow property owners in the coastal overlay district to offer short-term rentals at properties they don’t occupy, while requiring owners elsewhere in town to live at properties they rent on a short-term basis. 

Councilor Rose Van Dover, one of the two no votes, said the proposed restrictions amounted to too much government control. She also criticized proponents for not including information about Newport’s short-term rental regulations in Monday’s agenda packet. 

“I don’t understand what is going on here. You didn’t come prepared,” Van Dover said. “I want to protect those people. We allowed them to have these short term rentals and now we’re going to pull the rug out from underneath them? That’s wrong.” 

Councilor William Aiello, the other no vote, said, “The public’s getting screwed here, folks.”

Before the council’s debate, members of the public spoke mostly against new restrictions on short-term rentals. 

Rachel Jones said she and her husband purchased a property to rent through Airbnb because they see it as an investment in their children’s future.

Jones said she uses a local cleaner, provides renters with information on things to do in the area that support the local economy, and has housed workers from Electric Boat and others employed in military-related jobs. 

“What is the driving force behind this decision? Is it disruption? Is it owners that aren’t caring for their properties?” Jones said. “Because I can say we have invested a lot of money into the property that we purchased only a short time ago because we treat it like it is our home. And I think that should also be considered before making such a rash decision.”

Jake Malek, a Westerly resident and realtor with Malek Real Estate, said he and his wife own an Airbnb rental where they live part of the year. 

“It’s kind of the only way we would be able to afford a home in the area,” Malek said. “A lot of us here are in the position of where we own maybe one or two. I don’t think that this is the type of situation where we have investors scooping up houses and just turning them into rentals.”

Malek said he believes Westerly’s housing shortage is driven less by short-term rentals than by a lack of new homes affordable to many buyers. 

Westerly resident John Griggs said short-term rentals make it more difficult for people like him to find affordable housing. 

“I think we should focus more on the people that live here rather than the people that come and visit,” Griggs said.

Healy said Westerly currently has 442 registered short-term rentals. 

Conley said he would need to determine how potential restrictions would affect property owners already registered to offer short-term rentals, including whether the town would have to allow them to continue operating as nonconforming uses.

“Does registration in and of itself create a permitted use?” Conley said. “That is a question that we’re going to have to answer.”

Similar Posts